Sales Automation Systems Logo
Eric Partaker & Co.

800,000 cold emails. Zero confirmed customers attributed to cold email. The CEO still tells people to hire us.

Eric Partaker, "The CEO Coach" with 1.2M+ LinkedIn followers, hired us to answer one question: could cold email become a real channel for his CEO Accelerator? Four months and ~800,000 sends later, the answer was no. Our job was to tell him that. We did.

We do not guarantee cold email will work. We guarantee you will know if it can.

01Overview

At a Glance

~800,000
Emails sent
722,000+
Prospects reached
7,178
Replies
Zero
Confirmed customers attributed to cold email

"That clarity saved me from spending more money on something that wasn't going to pay off. I'd send anyone to Taylor who wants a straight answer more than a comfortable one."

Eric Partaker

The CEO Coach · Founder, CEO Accelerator

02Who Eric Partaker Is

Eric already had a channel that worked.

Eric Partaker

Eric Partaker

"The CEO Coach" · Founder, CEO Accelerator

1.2M+ LinkedIn followers. His first million took roughly 2.5 years.

Eric runs the CEO Accelerator, a 10-week cohort program for SMB founders and CEOs. He already had customers coming in before cold email came up:

  • A newsletter community he publicly counts at 235,000+ people.
  • The significant majority of his buyers already coming from LinkedIn.

He wasn't looking for cold email to save his business. He wanted to know if outbound could add to what already worked, without wasting money or damaging trust.

03Why He Hired Us

A question, not a request

On the first call, everyone agreed: cold email was unproven for his model. Eric didn't ask us to fill his calendar. He asked for an answer.

"I didn't know if cold email would work for my business. That's actually why I hired Taylor and the SAS team. I wanted someone who could give me a real answer."Eric Partaker

That's the job as we see it. We test one thing: can this offer reach this market through cold email at an acquisition cost that makes sense?

If the answer is yes, we scale. If the answer is no, we say so fast.

04The Experiment

How we tested cold email for a CEO with 1.2M followers

Phase 1 · Launch

Build and launch

We built the strategy and copy together: we drafted, Eric's team edited, and Eric added his own contrarian variant. The setup kept his brand protected. We used separate sending domains, randomized sender names, and scrubbed his customers and newsletter subscribers before every send.

Phase 2 · Month 1

Ramp and early signals

~100,000 emails out, with a live analytics dashboard for Eric's team. Reply rates tracked above benchmark. People replied, subscribed, and booked calls. Engagement was never the problem.

Phase 3 · Month 2

The hard call

About six weeks in, Taylor sent a Loom he knew Eric wouldn't love: strong replies, real traffic, but no paying customers. His honest read: cold email might not be viable for this business. Eric pushed back:

"While your hypothesis might be right, that cold email is not looking like a viable channel, it's definitely too early to base that off of meetings booked and purchases, thus far, as leading indicators."Eric Partaker

His cohort model meant the real test was still months away, at the next cohort's start date. Most of his buyers decide in the final days before a cohort opens. Taylor agreed, and both sides committed to going hard until then.

Phase 4 · Months 3 and 4

Free, past the contract

As the paid engagement wound down, Taylor offered to keep sending anyway:

"If it's alright with you I'm thinking of... just running the machine for free for at least a month. But I honestly might run it until [the cohort start] just to see what we can really do for you since it's such an odd sales cycle. And I don't want you to get burnt in case cold email just doesn't work for your type of business. Since we both knew that that was a gamble going into this."Taylor Haren · Founder, Sales Automation Systems
"Sure that sounds good. Thanks Taylor!"Eric Partaker

We ran the machine free for two more months. In the single week before the cohort deadline, we sent nearly half a million emails.

Phase 5 · Month 5

The answer

A few weeks after the cohort opened, the data was clear: cold email wasn't a viable acquisition channel for the CEO Accelerator. The engagement was there. The customers weren't. Eric reached out:

"Thanks so much for the work and for helping us reach a conclusion on cold email. Really appreciate it. Happy to do a testimonial."Eric Partaker

05What the Data Actually Said

Engagement wasn't the problem. Channel-offer fit was.

We didn't run a half-hearted test. Seven campaigns, 18 copy variants crossed with multiple calls-to-action, and a final sprint that put 523,000+ sends behind the single best performer.

102
positive replies
1.39%
bounce rate
40x
volume ramp

Throughout, reply rates stayed well above benchmark. People replied, subscribed to Eric's newsletter, and booked calls with his team. And yet:

Zero

confirmed paying customers from cold email.

The copy, infrastructure, and testing weren't the bottleneck. For this offer, at this price point, to this market, cold email just didn't create customers at a sensible acquisition cost.

06Why Zero Customers Was Still a Win

Why Zero Was a Win

Here's how Eric tells the story:

"They handled everything. Infrastructure, copy, attribution tracking, coordination with my team. Over four months they sent around 800,000 emails and reply rates were well above benchmark expectations. But none of those conversations turned into paying customers.

I'm still not entirely sure why. My best guess is that my ideal buyer just doesn't come through that channel, or at least isn't ready to buy when they get a cold email. What surprised me about Taylor is that he suspected this might happen before we even started, and he went all in anyway. When the results were still ambiguous, he offered to keep running campaigns for free past our contract so we'd have a clear answer. I've never had an agency do that.

I've worked with a lot of vendors. What stuck with me about SAS was how straightforward they were. No spin, no trying to make mediocre results look good. They wanted me to know the truth, even when the truth was 'this channel doesn't work for you.'

And honestly? That clarity saved me from spending more money on something that wasn't going to pay off. I'd send anyone to Taylor who wants a straight answer more than a comfortable one."

Eric Partaker

The CEO Coach · Founder, CEO Accelerator

Eric Partaker & Co.

Eric paid for a serious test. We ran it past the contract, free, until "maybe" was gone. The answer saved him from funding a channel his buyers don't use.

07What This Says About Us

The answer was no. We published it anyway.

"The whole point of hiring a cold email consultancy like ourselves is to figure out if outbound is a viable channel for your business. And if the answer is no, you need to know that as fast as possible so you can invest in what works."Taylor Haren · Founder, Sales Automation Systems

In Eric's case, the answer was no. For other clients, the answer has been "pour gas on it." Both outcomes are wins, as long as the answer is real.

This is the deal Taylor offers every client. Best case, we figure out how to turn cold email into a money printer for your business. Worst case, you reach the end of month three and you know cold email doesn't work for you. Not "five agencies later, I still feel like cold email should work and the agencies were just bad." You know.

The bar we hold ourselves to is the sentence Eric can say now: "Cold email didn't work for us. Sales Automation Systems did."

We do not guarantee cold email will work. We guarantee you will know if it can.

This story is for founders who:

  • Already have a channel that works.
  • Are skeptical of agency reporting.
  • Want a definitive yes or no on cold email, not twelve months of "one more test."

If you'd rather hear "this channel doesn't work for you" than be comforted with fuzzy metrics, we built SAS for you.

08Want a Straight Answer?

Want a straight answer on cold email?

If you're wondering whether outbound can be a real channel for your business, and you'd rather know the truth than be sold a dream, let's talk. We'll map your market, send from separate domains so your brand stays safe, test fast at real volume, and give you a definite answer inside a set window.

Sometimes the answer is "make money printer go brrr." Sometimes the answer is "your ICP just doesn't buy from cold email right now."

Either way, you'll know.

No guarantees of success. A guaranteed answer.